The 200-Day Rule on SPY Trailed Just Holding SPY
Last updated
In-sample, not a promise. Every figure we measured here comes from a backtest on past data.
Did exiting SPY below its 200-day average beat holding?
No. From October 2010 to September 2026, the 200-day rule returned 7.2% a year after trading costs, while holding SPY over the same window returned 12.5% a year. That is one rule on one index in a historical backtest, not a prediction or advice.
The 200-day moving-average timing rule (exit SPY when price crosses below its 200-day average, re-enter above it) returned 7.2% a year over 19 October 2010 to 11 September 2026. That is one rule on one index over one window, after trading costs.
Method. Daily SPY bars, the rule scored only once it has 200 bars of history, 10bps/side per switch trading cost charged on every switch.
Receipt: parameters, data, window and result file
- Run id
- not recorded
- Frozen parameters
- 200-day simple moving average; flat while price is below it, long above it; scored once 200 bars exist
- Data source
- SPY daily price cache; vendor not recorded
- Instruments and coverage
- SPY only
- Date window
- 19 October 2010 to 11 September 2026
- Sample
- not recorded
- Cost rule
- 10bps/side per switch charged per switch
- Fill rule
- not recorded
- Research-gate comparison (methodology)
- buying and holding SPY over the same window returned 12.5% a year
- Full result file
- not recorded; no result file is published for this figure
Did the 200-day rule make money on SPY?
It made 7.2% a year over 19 October 2010 to 11 September 2026, after 10bps/side per switch trading cost per switch. Holding SPY made 12.5% a year over the same window. That is a backtest of one rule on one index, not a prediction.
What period was this measured over?
19 October 2010 to 11 September 2026, the full window the SPY price cache covers once the rule has 200 bars to work with.
Is this Tickfloor's own performance?
No. This is a backtest of a specific rule (exit when price crosses below its 200-day average, re-enter above it) on one index, not a claim about Tickfloor's agreement score or any live trade.
Full context in the evidence page's registry of 1,346 tested strategies, or the strategy family index.
Other claims we've tested
Linked from this page
- Golden cross / death cross
- Moving average crossover
- Crypto 200-day line, golden cross and Uptober
- The concept page: Moving average crossover
- The concept page: Drawdown
Terms explained
Next steps
- See a full worked example (free, no account)
- Start lesson 1 of the course (free)
- Run your own version of this rule in the Backtest Lab (needs a pass)
General information only. It doesn't consider your objectives, finances or needs. Tickfloor holds no financial services licence and never places trades.