Tickfloor

Volume profile POC pullback after a break of structure: does it work?

Last updated

In-sample, not a promise. Every figure we measured here comes from a backtest on past data.

Does the volume profile POC strategy work?

These versions did not pass our tests. All 8 pre-registered versions lost money after modelled costs in both the development split (1 January 2021 to 31 December 2023) and the test split (1 January 2024 to 30 September 2026) on 8 Binance USD-M perpetuals. Test win rates were 43.6% to 51.8% and expectancy was -0.087R to -0.169R a trade.

A viral short-form video teaches this: in a downtrend, mark the last break of structure, draw a fixed-range volume profile from the lower high to the lower low, find the point of control (POC, the price with the most volume), wait for price to retrace into it with some breathing room, then short and aim for the lower low. Longs are the mirror image.

Results

Configuration (test split)TradesWin rate (95% CI)Expectancy, net (test)Profit factorExpectancy, net (dev)
3-bar swings, 15m, POC8,10749.8% (48.7 to 50.9)-0.141R0.76-0.177R
3-bar swings, 15m, POC with room7,07751.8% (50.6 to 52.9)-0.139R0.75-0.153R
3-bar swings, 1h, POC2,26543.6% (41.5 to 45.6)-0.169R0.73-0.061R
3-bar swings, 1h, POC with room1,97848.2% (46.0 to 50.5)-0.122R0.78-0.034R
5-bar swings, 15m, POC5,51148.7% (47.4 to 50.0)-0.138R0.76-0.146R
5-bar swings, 15m, POC with room4,87551.4% (50.0 to 52.9)-0.132R0.76-0.124R
5-bar swings, 1h, POC1,52445.0% (42.5 to 47.6)-0.131R0.78-0.083R
5-bar swings, 1h, POC with room1,25448.6% (45.8 to 51.4)-0.087R0.84-0.039R
  • 3-bar swings, 15m, POC
    Trades
    8,107
    Win rate (95% CI)
    49.8% (48.7 to 50.9)
    Expectancy, net (test)
    -0.141R
    Profit factor
    0.76
    Expectancy, net (dev)
    -0.177R
  • 3-bar swings, 15m, POC with room
    Trades
    7,077
    Win rate (95% CI)
    51.8% (50.6 to 52.9)
    Expectancy, net (test)
    -0.139R
    Profit factor
    0.75
    Expectancy, net (dev)
    -0.153R
  • 3-bar swings, 1h, POC
    Trades
    2,265
    Win rate (95% CI)
    43.6% (41.5 to 45.6)
    Expectancy, net (test)
    -0.169R
    Profit factor
    0.73
    Expectancy, net (dev)
    -0.061R
  • 3-bar swings, 1h, POC with room
    Trades
    1,978
    Win rate (95% CI)
    48.2% (46.0 to 50.5)
    Expectancy, net (test)
    -0.122R
    Profit factor
    0.78
    Expectancy, net (dev)
    -0.034R
  • 5-bar swings, 15m, POC
    Trades
    5,511
    Win rate (95% CI)
    48.7% (47.4 to 50.0)
    Expectancy, net (test)
    -0.138R
    Profit factor
    0.76
    Expectancy, net (dev)
    -0.146R
  • 5-bar swings, 15m, POC with room
    Trades
    4,875
    Win rate (95% CI)
    51.4% (50.0 to 52.9)
    Expectancy, net (test)
    -0.132R
    Profit factor
    0.76
    Expectancy, net (dev)
    -0.124R
  • 5-bar swings, 1h, POC
    Trades
    1,524
    Win rate (95% CI)
    45.0% (42.5 to 47.6)
    Expectancy, net (test)
    -0.131R
    Profit factor
    0.78
    Expectancy, net (dev)
    -0.083R
  • 5-bar swings, 1h, POC with room
    Trades
    1,254
    Win rate (95% CI)
    48.6% (45.8 to 51.4)
    Expectancy, net (test)
    -0.087R
    Profit factor
    0.84
    Expectancy, net (dev)
    -0.039R

All eight versions lost money after modelled costs in both the development and the test split. The smallest p-value for "expectancy above zero" in the test split was 0.996, and the smallest Benjamini-Hochberg q across all controls was 1.00. The tested configurations did not pass on these data and assumptions (after modeled taker fees and slippage; funding excluded).

What happened

None of the eight tested versions passed. Before costs, expectancy in the test split ran from -0.070R to +0.011R a trade, so there is no gross edge for fees and slippage to eat. The version that looked best on the development data (3-bar swings, 1h, POC with room, -0.034R) carried to the test split at -0.122R, so picking the best configuration did not survive out of sample. Across all eight configurations and six years, 47 of 48 config-years were negative, and longs and shorts were equally bad on the test split (-0.137R and -0.137R). Funding payments, tested separately, moved expectancy by no more than 0.0012R a trade.

Why a win rate near 50% does not rescue it

A win rate around 50% sounds fine until you read the profit factor. With the stop at the lower high and the target at the lower low, the average win is not large enough to cover the average loss plus fees and slippage, so the profit factor sits between 0.73 and 0.84 on the test split. Test win rates ran from 43.6% to 51.8%, and several versions win about half their trades and still lose 0.087R to 0.169R each time.

Does the POC add anything?

Not in these tests. A control that uses the same swings but enters at the 50% retracement lost less than the POC entry in 8 of 8 test configurations, so the volume profile did not improve the entry. We also withdraw an earlier claim about direction. A first run suggested that the strategy's direction beat a coin-flip direction in two configurations (p-values of 0.002 and 0.002). That came from a bug: the coin-flip control could be charged a stop that was hit before its entry. With the bug fixed the same two comparisons give p = 0.33 and 0.48, and across all eight configurations the range is 0.22 to 0.96. There is no evidence that the direction carries information, and no claim that it beats a coin flip. A control with the same stop and target distances entered at random bars gave a minimum q of 1.00 for beating the strategy in the wrong direction; none of the controls separated from the strategy.

The exact rules we tested

The exact rules we tested

  • Swings: pivots with 3 or 5 bars on each side. A down setup needs a lower high, a lower low, and a candle close below the prior low (the break of structure; wicks do not count).
  • Volume profile: 40 price bins across the leg from the lower high to the lower low, each bar's volume spread across its range. POC is the centre of the busiest bin.
  • Entry: a limit order at the POC, or at the POC minus 10% of the leg for the "breathing room" version. Stop at the lower high, target at the lower low, order cancelled after 48 bars.
  • Data: 8 Binance USD-M perpetuals (BTC, ETH, SOL, BNB, XRP, DOGE, ADA, LINK) on 15-minute and 1-hour bars. Costs 0.04% taker fee and 0.02% slippage per side; funding payments are not in the headline numbers (their size is reported below). Results are in R, where 1R is the distance from entry to stop.
  • Splits: development 1 January 2021 to 31 December 2023, test 1 January 2024 to 30 September 2026. All 8 configurations (3 or 5 bar swings, 15m or 1h, two entries) were declared in a pre-registration file committed together with the results, so the order of writing and running cannot be independently shown.
Receipt: parameters, data, window and result file
Run id
VPPOC-1002 v2
Frozen parameters
pre-registered 8 configurations: swing pivot window N of 3 or 5, 15-minute or 1-hour bars, entry at the POC or at the POC less 10% of the leg; 40 volume-profile bins
Data source
Binance USD-M futures klines (data.binance.vision); gold from Dukascopy tick volume as a supplement
Instruments and coverage
8 Binance USD-M perpetuals
Date window
1 January 2021 to 30 September 2026; development 1 January 2021 to 31 December 2023, test 1 January 2024 to 30 September 2026
Sample
trades, assigned to the split of their signal bar; counts per configuration are in the results table
Cost rule
taker fee 0.04% per side plus slippage 0.02% per side; funding excluded from the headline
Fill rule
limit order at the entry level placed at the close of the confirming bar; skipped if price has already passed it
Benchmark
none; 50% retracement, coin-flip and random-bar controls
Result file
not published: the study files live in Tickfloor's private repo, not the public research repo
Controls and multiplicity

Controls

Three controls were run per configuration: entering at the 50% retracement, a coin-flip direction at the same fill bars, and a random-bar entry with the same stop and target distances. The luck check (p-values corrected with Benjamini-Hochberg) ran across the tests in each split. The pre-registered verdict needed a configuration with positive test expectancy at q below 0.05 that also beat all three controls. no tested configuration passed. Intervals use week-block resampling, because trades on different coins in the same week are not independent.

Limits and caveats

Limits

A second run (v2) was made after an independent audit of the first and fixed several execution and labelling defects. It changed some counts slightly and changed no verdict. This tests a mechanical version. A discretionary trader who only takes the visually clean setups cannot be tested this way. The clip's "breathing room" is vague, so we tested the POC and the POC minus 10% of the leg. Fill assumptions are simplified: fees are charged as taker fees even on limit fills and we did not test more favourable assumptions, so the results are after modelled fees and slippage only. Positions across coins are correlated, so the effective sample is smaller than the trade count. As a supplement we ran gold (Dukascopy XAUUSD, 15 minute) using tick volume, which is a proxy rather than exchange volume, with no fee. The first gold download was defective; after a clean refetch all eight gold configurations had negative test expectancy (-0.144R to -0.050R on 107 to 297 trades each, best q = 0.92). The earlier mixed signs on gold came from the defective data.

General information only. It doesn't consider your objectives, finances or needs. Tickfloor holds no financial services licence and never places trades.

Short answers (FAQ)

Is the point of control better than a plain 50% retracement?

In these tests, no. Entering at the 50% retracement lost less than the POC entry in 8 of 8 test configurations, so the volume profile did not improve the entry.

Does the direction of the trade beat a coin flip?

We found no evidence of it. An earlier suggestion came from a control bug; after the fix the comparison p-values range from 0.22 to 0.96.

Did it work on gold?

No. After a clean data refetch all eight gold configurations had negative test expectancy (-0.144R to -0.050R), none significant. Gold was a supplement, using tick volume, and was not part of the verdict.

Is this financial advice?

No. This measures a publicly claimed trading rule, not a recommendation. General information only, not personal advice.

How we set the rules, costs and pass bar before running anything: the Tickfloor testing standard. The wider record is on the evidence page. Another viral claim we tested: Opening range breakout with an 81% win rate: does it work?. All the rules we tested.

Terms explained