Do trading strategies work? 70 popular rules, tested
Last updated
The rules did not pass the tests Tickfloor ran. Of 1,346 strategies backtested net of modelled costs, 0 passed the corrected test. That does not prove no strategy works, and it says nothing about versions that were not tested. These are results from our older test setup, which was built before our current testing rules. They have not been redone under those rules.
Each page below takes one rule people often repeat. We code it from its source's description where there is one, test it with trading costs against a benchmark, and show how many trades it made and whether it passed our luck check. On most pages the benchmark is an equal-weight basket of the same assets; the rest use random entries or other comparisons. Pick the rule you have been told about.
Trending in autumn 2026
- Opening range breakout (ORB), hourly crypto versiondid not pass
- ICT Asia session liquidity sweep, hourly crypto versiondid not pass
- VWAP plus 9 EMA, hourly crypto versiondid not pass
- 9/21 EMA crossoverdid not pass
- Crypto 200-day line, golden cross and Uptoberdid not pass
Indicator rules
- RSI trading strategydid not pass
- RSI(2) mean reversiondid not pass
- MACD crossoverdid not pass
- MACD + RSI confluencedid not pass
- StochRSI crossdid not pass
- Stochastic, CCI and Williams %Rdid not pass
- ADX and parabolic SARdid not pass
- Bollinger band bouncedid not pass
- Bollinger band squeezedid not pass
- VWAP bouncedid not pass
- Ichimoku clouddid not pass
- Fibonacci retracementdid not pass
Trend, moving averages and breakouts
- Moving average crossoverdid not pass
- Golden cross / death crossdid not pass
- 9/21 EMA crossoverdid not pass
- The 200-day rule on SPYdid not pass
- Donchian / Turtle breakoutdid not pass
- Crypto trend followingdid not pass
- Dual momentum (GEM)did not pass
- 12-1 month momentumdid not pass
- 52-week highdid not pass
Chart patterns and price action
- Candlestick patternsdid not pass
- Support and resistancedid not pass
- The TJR / ICT sweep and fair value gap modeldid not pass
- Opening range breakout, 81% win ratedid not pass
- Volume profile POC pullbackdid not pass
Calendar and seasonal effects
- Turn-of-the-month effectdid not pass
- Sell in Maydid not pass
- The January effectdid not pass
- Santa Claus rallydid not pass
- Crypto weekend effectdid not pass
Sentiment, volatility and crypto positioning
- Fear & Greed indexdid not pass
- Fear & Greed timingdid not pass
- VIX term structure timingdid not pass
- Funding rate and open interestdid not pass
- Buy the dipdid not pass
- Low-beta cryptodid not pass
- Pairs tradingdid not pass
More rules we tested
- ICT liquidity sweepdid not pass
- Order blocksdid not pass
- Break of structuredid not pass
- Fair value gapdid not pass
- ICT and smart money conceptsdid not pass
- Supertrenddid not pass
- Connors double 7did not pass
- Bull market support banddid not pass
- Mayer multipledid not pass
- Bitcoin halving cycledid not pass
- Awesome oscillatordid not pass
- Bollinger band breakoutdid not pass
- Turnaround Tuesdaydid not pass
- Gold/silver ratiodid not pass
- Squeeze momentumdid not pass
- Larry Williams volatility breakoutdid not pass
- 20 EMA pullbackdid not pass
- Guppy GMMAdid not pass
- Cup and handledid not pass
- Head and shouldersdid not pass
- Heikin-Ashidid not pass
- RSI divergencedid not pass
- Keltner channel breakoutdid not pass
- Pivot point R1 breakoutdid not pass
- Trendline breakoutdid not pass
- Overnight gap fadedid not pass
- IBS mean reversiondid not pass
By market
- Crypto pairs: 510 strategies testednone passed
- US stocks: 470 strategies testednone passed
- ETFs: 366 strategies testednone passed
How were these rules chosen?
These are the rules that come up most in trading videos, forums and tutorials, plus the well-known published ones. Most were coded from the source's description of the rule, as we interpreted it. The page for each rule says what was actually implemented, and where that differs from the popular teaching.
What does 'net of costs' mean?
Every trade in the backtest pays an estimated cost for each side of the trade. A rule that looks good before costs and bad after them did not survive the modelled costs; real fills, fees and slippage can differ.
Is this advice?
No. This reports what happened to a set of rules in the past. General information only, not personal advice.
Next steps
- See a full worked example (free, no account)
- Start lesson 1 of the course (free)
- Run your own version of a rule in the Backtest Lab (needs a pass)
General information only. It doesn't consider your objectives, finances or needs. Tickfloor holds no financial services licence and never places trades.