Does the ICT Asia session liquidity sweep work? An hourly crypto version, backtested
Last updated
In-sample, not a promise. Every figure we measured here comes from a backtest on past data.
Does the ICT liquidity sweep work?
Our hourly crypto version, without the structure confirmation, did not pass our pre-set test, and 0 of 1,057 sweep rules in our earlier multi-market study survived the multiple-test correction. We have not tested the full discretionary model.
This hourly crypto version did not pass our pre-set test. The best-faith version beat 0 of 200 copies placed at random times, made -21.6% a year before costs and -48.1% after. In our earlier study, 0 of 1,057 liquidity-sweep rules survived the correction for multiple tests.
Hypothetical historical backtest on cached data to March 2025, not live results and not indicative of future performance. General information only. It doesn't consider your objectives, finances or needs. Tickfloor holds no financial services licence and never places trades.
Correction, 6 October 2026: what we fixed after review
What people say
ICT and smart money ideas were the largest keyword cluster in the trading subreddits we sampled. The session version goes like this: the Asia session builds a range, London runs the stops above or below it, and once price closes back inside you trade the reversal after a change in structure. The stop goes past the sweep wick, the target is twice the risk, and the stop moves to break-even at 1R.
- "Step 3: Mark out Asia high/low + London high/low" (r/Daytrading post, 13 Sep 2026)
- "SL to structural low/high, TP at 2R." (same post)
- "B/E after 1R. Full TP at 2R." (same post)
In our archive sample of five trading subreddits (1 September to 5 October 2026), 240 posts mentioned ICT, smart money or fair value gaps, the largest keyword count we recorded (counts not cleaned of noise). The post quoted above had 413 upvotes when archived. On YouTube, Smart Risk's "Stop Trading Liquidity Sweeps Until You Watch This!" had 97,753 views on 5 October.
What we tested
This is a proxy, not the full posted model. The rule as posted runs on 1-minute and 5-minute futures charts and waits for a change in structure. Our harness has hourly crypto, which trades through the Asia and London sessions, so we ran the session sweep there without the structure confirmation: a candle that pierces the Asia level and closes back past it. We wrote the rules, the costs and the pass bar down before running it. Three versions, plus the daily cousin from an earlier batch, plus one no-stop version added in the 6 October amendment.
- Asia range swept in London, wick stop, break-even after 1R, 2R target, out at the 21:00 UTC close. Mark the high and low of the Asia session (the hourly bars from 00:00 to 07:00 UTC). On an hourly bar between 07:00 and 12:00 UTC, if price trades below the Asia low and closes back above it, buy at that close. Stop at that bar's low, R = entry minus stop. Move the stop to break-even once a close is 1R up; take profit on a close 2R up; close anything left at the 21:00 UTC close. Mirror image for a sweep of the Asia high. One trade a day. Two details of the code: a bar that pierces both sides is skipped only if it closes back inside on both, and a long needs only a close back above the Asia low, not a close inside the range.
- Same sweep, wick stop, 2R target, no break-even step. The same sweep and wick stop, 2R target, no break-even step.
- Same sweep, wick stop, no target (archived as 'no stop or target'; it kept the wick stop). The same sweep entry, the wick stop, and no target, out at the 21:00 UTC close. We first labelled this "no stop or target"; it kept the wick stop.
- Same sweep entry, no stop and no target, out at the 21:00 UTC close. The same sweep entry with no stop and no target: hold to the 21:00 UTC close. Registered in the 6 October amendment and run once.
- Daily cousin: failed 20-day breakdown on ETFs (turtle soup, earlier run). The daily-chart cousin on 25 ETFs: price breaks a 20-day low and closes back above it the same day, hold 5 days. Reused from an earlier batch.
Results
| Version | Market (assets) | Trades | Rule, a year (after costs) | Benchmark, a year | Ahead or behind, a year | Same, before costs | Random copies beaten (share of 200) | p | q (all tests) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Asia range swept in London, wick stop, break-even after 1R, 2R target, out at the 21:00 UTC close | crypto (8) | 10,188 | -48.1% | 84.7% | -132.8 pts | -106.3 pts | 0.0% | 1.00 | 1.00 |
| Same sweep, wick stop, 2R target, no break-even step | crypto (8) | 10,188 | -48.5% | 84.7% | -133.2 pts | -106.8 pts | 0.0% | 1.00 | 1.00 |
| Same sweep, wick stop, no target (archived as 'no stop or target'; it kept the wick stop) | crypto (8) | 10,188 | -47.7% | 84.7% | -132.5 pts | -105.8 pts | 0.5% | 1.00 | 1.00 |
| Same sweep entry, no stop and no target, out at the 21:00 UTC close | crypto (8) | 10,188 | -43.3% | 84.7% | -128.0 pts | -99.0 pts | 15.0% | 1.00 | 1.00 |
| Daily cousin: failed 20-day breakdown on ETFs (turtle soup, earlier run) | ETFs (25) | 687 | -0.4% | 7.0% | -7.4 pts | -7.1 pts | 9.5% | 1.00 | 1.00 |
- Asia range swept in London, wick stop, break-even after 1R, 2R target, out at the 21:00 UTC close
- Market (assets)
- crypto (8)
- Trades
- 10,188
- Rule, a year (after costs)
- -48.1%
- Benchmark, a year
- 84.7%
- Ahead or behind, a year
- -132.8 pts
- Same, before costs
- -106.3 pts
- Random copies beaten (share of 200)
- 0.0%
- p
- 1.00
- q (all tests)
- 1.00
- Same sweep, wick stop, 2R target, no break-even step
- Market (assets)
- crypto (8)
- Trades
- 10,188
- Rule, a year (after costs)
- -48.5%
- Benchmark, a year
- 84.7%
- Ahead or behind, a year
- -133.2 pts
- Same, before costs
- -106.8 pts
- Random copies beaten (share of 200)
- 0.0%
- p
- 1.00
- q (all tests)
- 1.00
- Same sweep, wick stop, no target (archived as 'no stop or target'; it kept the wick stop)
- Market (assets)
- crypto (8)
- Trades
- 10,188
- Rule, a year (after costs)
- -47.7%
- Benchmark, a year
- 84.7%
- Ahead or behind, a year
- -132.5 pts
- Same, before costs
- -105.8 pts
- Random copies beaten (share of 200)
- 0.5%
- p
- 1.00
- q (all tests)
- 1.00
- Same sweep entry, no stop and no target, out at the 21:00 UTC close
- Market (assets)
- crypto (8)
- Trades
- 10,188
- Rule, a year (after costs)
- -43.3%
- Benchmark, a year
- 84.7%
- Ahead or behind, a year
- -128.0 pts
- Same, before costs
- -99.0 pts
- Random copies beaten (share of 200)
- 15.0%
- p
- 1.00
- q (all tests)
- 1.00
- Daily cousin: failed 20-day breakdown on ETFs (turtle soup, earlier run)
- Market (assets)
- ETFs (25)
- Trades
- 687
- Rule, a year (after costs)
- -0.4%
- Benchmark, a year
- 7.0%
- Ahead or behind, a year
- -7.4 pts
- Same, before costs
- -7.1 pts
- Random copies beaten (share of 200)
- 9.5%
- p
- 1.00
- q (all tests)
- 1.00
Read the numbers with this in mind. The benchmark is always fully invested and pays no costs, and from 2017 to early 2025 crypto rose a lot, so any rule that spends much of its time in cash trails it by a wide margin almost automatically. That gap answers a narrow question, not whether the rule is useful. So we also compare each rule with 200 copies of itself: its own trades, with the same holding times, the same long and short sides and the same costs, shifted together to a random point in time, the same shift for every market it trades. Those copies are in the market exactly as much as the rule is, so they ask a different question: did the rule pick better moments than chance? The copies are not held to the same hours of the day. The sweep versions sit in a trade only about 10% of the time, so the random copies matter most here.
The bottom chart compares the rule with its random copies. If buying the reclaim after a London sweep picked better moments than chance, the rule would sit to the right of the grey bars. It beat 0 of 200.
What costs do to it
Crypto pays 0.10% a side plus a per-coin slippage measured from the Binance order book on 8 September 2026 for a $1,000 order, applied to the whole 2017 to 2025 window (a present-day snapshot, not historical spreads). US stocks and ETFs pay 0.05% a side. The cost is charged every time the position changes, including a flip from long to short. Shorts pay no borrow or funding; their net effect is not measured here. The sweep rules trade at most once a day per coin, 10,188 trades in all. Costs moved the best-faith version from -21.6% to -48.1% a year. It was losing before any cost was charged.
The index and forex version, from our earlier study
Earlier this month we tested 1,057 liquidity-concept rules (previous day and week high or low sweeps, session sweeps, equal highs and lows and more) on the Nasdaq-100 and S&P 500 indexes (CFD prices, not futures), EURUSD and USDJPY, 29 US stocks, QQQ and crypto, 1,376,544 trades in all, each compared with random entries at the same time of day. 0 survived the correction for the number of tests.
On the index CFDs alone, 141 of 230 rules lost money before costs. The sweeps did no better than random entries at the same minute of the day.
What the result does and does not show
The idea assumes that a sweep of an obvious level is a trap, and that price turns once the stops are taken. In this hourly crypto data, the sweep trades beat 0 of 200 copies of themselves placed at random times, and lost money before costs.
We compared four exits on the same entry: break-even at 1R, a plain 2R target, the wick stop with no target, and (added in the amendment) no stop at all. They made -48.1%, -48.5%, -47.7% and -43.3% a year after costs. Four exits on one dataset cannot say on their own why a rule fails, so we do not draw that conclusion.
This does not test the posted model with its structure confirmation on futures. The posts that make this look easy are short streaks: a week of wins and a payout. Random entries produce streaks like that too, which is why a backtest over years and a comparison with chance matter.
What a beginner should take away
- Learn what a liquidity sweep is, because people will talk about it. In our hourly crypto version, a sweep did not mark better entries than random times.
- Changing the stop and target is easy; checking whether the entry beats random times is the harder and more useful test.
- Short winning streaks, including your own, are weak evidence. Compare them with random entries over the same days.
Try it yourself
The Backtest Lab works on daily bars and cannot mark Asia and London ranges, so it cannot run this rule or reproduce the basket test above. A related daily exercise about buying after a drop, not this rule: on SPY, set the entry to rsi(2) below 10 and the exit to price crosses above sma(5), then read its win rate, average trade and worst drop.
The Lab tests one rule on one stock, fills at the next open and shows win rate, average trade and worst drop after costs, so its figures will not match the basket results above.
A pass opens every course lesson, the full research tabs and more Lab runs on all 50 Lab stocks. It does not include trade signals or a system that wins.
Receipt: data, costs, files
- Engine
- Tickfloor research harness (research/hunt2), the one behind the published strategy registry
- Pre-registration
- prereg.md, committed before any run; prereg-amendment-2026-10-06.md and prereg-amendment-2026-10-06b.md, each committed before its corrected runs
- Random control
- Version 3 (6 October 2026): every copy is the rule's own trades shifted to a random point in time, the same shift for every market it trades
- Window
- 17 August 2017 to 14 March 2025 for the best-faith version; data stops before 15 March 2025 (later data is held back)
- Cells
- tr5-ict-asia-sweep-be, tr5-ict-asia-sweep-2r, tr5-ict-asia-sweep-hold, tr5a-ict-asia-sweep-nostop, s29-etf-turtle-soup (earlier run, reused)
- Multiple testing
- q is Benjamini-Hochberg over all 722 tests in the published family, these included
- Result files
- results-amended-2026-10-06b.json (current), results-amended-2026-10-06.json (control v2, superseded) and results.json (archived, as first published), with every rule's code and sha256 hashes
Limits and caveats
Limits
The posted rule uses 1 to 5 minute charts and a discretionary change-in-structure confirmation. We tested a mechanical, hourly version on crypto without it. A different definition of the confirmation would give different numbers.
Exits are on hourly closes, not intrabar fills.
The random copies are not held to the same hours of the day.
Shorts pay no borrow or funding cost here; the net effect is not measured.
Correction, 6 October 2026
- Our random-date copies had a bug. When two copies of trades in the same direction landed next to each other, they merged into one trade, and the exit and re-entry costs between them were never charged. So the copies traded less and paid less than the rule they were copying, which made the rule look worse against them. We fixed the code so every copy keeps the rule's trade count and costs, wrote the fix down in a dated amendment before re-running, and re-ran every copy. A second check the same day found a deeper problem. The fixed copies still moved each market's trades on their own, so a rule that is in many related markets at the same moments (a moving-average rule on 8 crypto pairs, say) was compared with copies that spread those bets out. Spread-out bets bunch more tightly, so the rule landed far above or far below its copies too often: coin-flip rules beat 95% of their copies about three times as often as chance allows, mostly on US stocks. We changed the copies again, wrote that down in a second dated amendment before re-running, and re-ran every copy. Each copy now shifts the rule's own trades to a random point in time, the same shift for every market. On 600 coin-flip rules, 7.0% (same timing in every market) and 5.3% (own timing per market) now beat 95% of their copies, close to the 5% chance allows. On this page: copies beaten out of 200, as first published, after the first fix and now: break-even version: 0 -> 0 -> 0; 2R version: 0 -> 0 -> 0; wick stop, no target: 1 -> 0 -> 1; no stop (new): new -> 11 -> 30; daily ETF cousin: 24 -> 22 -> 19.
- The version we called "no stop or target" kept the wick stop; only the target was removed. It is now labelled "wick stop, no target". The real no-stop version was registered in the amendment and run once: -43.3% a year after costs, 30 of 200 random copies beaten. We removed our claim that "when the exits do not matter, the entry is the problem": it rested on the mislabelled version.
- We said a bar sweeping both sides is skipped and that entries need a close back inside the range. The code skips a two-sided bar only if it closes back inside on both sides, and a long needs only a close back above the Asia low. The rule text now says what the code does; the result is unchanged.
- We gave times as bar openings. The 20:00 exit happens at the 21:00 UTC close. We called the trade count "position changes"; it counts trades.
The original pre-registration, results and test ledger are unchanged; these corrections are new, dated files. Evidence files
Short answers (FAQ)
Did you test fair value gaps?
Yes, separately, in our TJR model page and the earlier study. They did not pass either. This page is about the Asia and London session sweep.
Is ICT a scam?
We cannot speak to anyone's intent. We can say that the mechanical rules we built from ICT ideas did not pass our tests.
Is this advice?
No. It reports what happened to a set of rules in a historical backtest. General information only.
More trending techniques we tested
- Does the opening range breakout work? An hourly crypto version, backtested
- Does the VWAP and 9 EMA strategy work? An hourly crypto version, backtested
- Does the 9/21 EMA crossover work? We tested it on thousands of trades
- The 200-day line, the golden cross and Uptober: tested on 18 coins including Bitcoin
- Five widely discussed trading techniques of autumn 2026, tested
- Every popular rule we tested
How we set the rules, costs and pass bar before running anything: the Tickfloor testing standard. The wider record is on the evidence page.