TJR / ICT liquidity sweep + fair value gap: does it work?
Last updated
In-sample, not a promise. Every figure we measured here comes from a backtest on past data.
Does the TJR liquidity sweep and fair value gap strategy work?
Not in our tests. The frozen sweep, confirmation and pullback-entry sequence took 24 trades across 23 crypto pairs in a discovery window from 1 March 2024 to 1 March 2025 and averaged -0.878R per trade after costs. One trade reached its full target, 19 were stopped out and 4 expired.
The TJR model, closely related to ICT and "smart money" concepts, teaches one sequence: price sweeps a prior high or low (the liquidity sweep), a candle closes back through a short-term swing to confirm, and you enter on a pullback, often into a fair value gap (a three-candle price gap). Tickfloor coded that sequence and tested it.
What came back
The rule produced 24 trades: 1 reached its full target, 19 hit the stop and 4 expired. That is -21.068R in total and -0.878R per trade after costs (R is the amount risked on one trade), with a 95% interval of -1.830R to +0.075R. Both halves of the window lost, at -0.924R and -0.839R. A first look at five symbols had shown +5.102R from four trades; on the complete set the same rule lost.
| Version | Trades | Target / stop / expiry | Total | Per trade |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Baseline, NY session, frozen rule | 24 | 1 / 19 / 4 | -21.068R | -0.878R |
| Bias gate relaxed to 1h only | 65 | 8 / 52 / 5 | -55.011R | -0.846R |
| No bias gate | 108 | 15 / 87 / 6 | -84.853R | -0.786R |
| Wider NY window | 48 | 5 / 35 / 8 | -25.436R | -0.530R |
| London window | 35 | 10 / 25 / 0 | -22.299R | -0.637R |
| Fixed 2R target | 30 | 6 / 20 / 4 | -26.968R | -0.899R |
- Baseline, NY session, frozen rule
- Trades
- 24
- Target / stop / expiry
- 1 / 19 / 4
- Total
- -21.068R
- Per trade
- -0.878R
- Bias gate relaxed to 1h only
- Trades
- 65
- Target / stop / expiry
- 8 / 52 / 5
- Total
- -55.011R
- Per trade
- -0.846R
- No bias gate
- Trades
- 108
- Target / stop / expiry
- 15 / 87 / 6
- Total
- -84.853R
- Per trade
- -0.786R
- Wider NY window
- Trades
- 48
- Target / stop / expiry
- 5 / 35 / 8
- Total
- -25.436R
- Per trade
- -0.530R
- London window
- Trades
- 35
- Target / stop / expiry
- 10 / 25 / 0
- Total
- -22.299R
- Per trade
- -0.637R
- Fixed 2R target
- Trades
- 30
- Target / stop / expiry
- 6 / 20 / 4
- Total
- -26.968R
- Per trade
- -0.899R
Loosening the rules gave more trades and a bigger total loss each time, and none of the variants were positive. Nothing came back positive, so there was no winner to correct for.
Receipt: parameters, data, window and result file
- Run id
- not recorded; the replay's output files are docs_tjr_runs/baseline.json and its variant and control files in Tickfloor's private repo
- Frozen parameters
- liquidity sweep, confirming close through a short-term swing, then pullback entry into a fair value gap; frozen before results were read (exact thresholds are in the replay script, not recorded on this page)
- Data source
- cached crypto candles, vendor not recorded on this page
- Instruments and coverage
- 23 crypto pairs with a complete cached history, 5-minute candles, New York morning window (196,749 candles checked)
- Date window
- 1 March 2024 to 1 March 2025 (discovery window only; holdout never read)
- Sample
- 24 completed trades
- Cost rule
- 0.10% fee per side plus slippage, with 5x slippage on stops; a stop wins if stop and target are hit in the same candle
- Fill rule
- pullback entry after the confirming close; same-candle stop-and-target resolves to the stop
- Benchmark
- random entries with the same symbol, cost, stop and target ladder (10,000 matched portfolios)
- Result file
- not published: the replay files are in Tickfloor's private repo, not the public research repo
What we ran (exact method)
What we ran
The rule was frozen before the results were read and run on all 23 crypto pairs with a complete cached history, at every closed 5-minute candle in the New York morning window (196,749 candles checked), using only data from 1 March 2024 to 1 March 2025. Costs were 0.10% fee per side plus slippage, with 5x slippage on stops, and a stop wins if a stop and target are hit in the same candle. The holdout data was never read.
Against random entries
Each of the 24 trades was re-run with the same symbol, cost, stop and target ladder but a random day and time inside the same window. Across 10,000 matched portfolios the average was -0.857R per trade against the model's -0.878R, and 49.1% of them beat it. Randomising only the time of day, on the same days, averaged -1.183R, and 7.6% beat the model.
The wider grid
Separately, 270 tests of fair value gap fills, liquidity sweep reversals and market structure breaks (30 assets, 15-minute, 1-hour and 4-hour bars, nine exit settings, costs and per-asset slippage charged) had 0 survivors after Benjamini-Hochberg correction and none cleared the trade bar. The best row was a DOGE 4-hour fair value gap fill at +0.113R per trade, p=0.0875, which is what the best of 270 tries looks like by luck. Published backtests by StatOasis on SPY reported 648 backtests with 1 of 32 scores clearing t of 2 (as reported).
Limits and caveats
Limits
The 24 trades are a small sample, the pairs are the ones with a complete cache rather than a point-in-time listing, and the test covers crypto, not the NQ and ES futures the teacher trades. The optimal trade entry (OTE) zone was not part of the 270-test grid, and order blocks cannot be tested as taught because no source gives a numeric rule. None of this is a claim about any individual trader.
How to check any price-action claim
- Write each step as a time and a price, and check you could have known it at the moment you enter. A fair value gap only exists once its third candle has closed.
- Charge fees and slippage, and count every stopped trade, not only the ones shown on the chart.
- Compare with random entries of the same size, not with zero.
- Count how many variants were tried. The best of 270 will look good.
General information only. It doesn't consider your objectives, finances or needs. Tickfloor holds no financial services licence and never places trades.
Short answers (FAQ)
Did it beat picking random entries?
No. Keeping each trade's symbol, costs, stop and target ladder but drawing a random day and time, 49.1% of 10,000 matched 24-trade portfolios did better than the model, which is what chance looks like. Random entries on the same day did worse, so the sequence may help with timing on days already chosen, but it did not pick better days.
Was it a wider test than one rule?
Yes. A separate grid of 270 tests (fair value gap fills, liquidity sweep reversals and market structure breaks, across 30 assets, three timeframes and nine exit settings, costs charged) had 0 survivors after Benjamini-Hochberg correction. The best row, a DOGE 4-hour fair value gap fill, showed +0.113R per trade at p=0.0875.
Does this prove the method never works?
No. The replay is discovery-only, crypto-only and small (24 trades, so the 95% interval of -1.830R to +0.075R is wide). Order blocks are not testable as taught because no source gives a numeric rule, and the optimal trade entry (OTE) zone was not tested by the 270-test grid. The result shows no edge in what we could code, not that no trader anywhere has one.
Is this financial advice?
No. This reports a backtest of a publicly taught rule. General information only, not personal advice.
The numbers come from Tickfloor's research log; the method and every strategy result are on the evidence page, and the wider strategy family index lists the rest.
Other claims we tested and how Tickfloor compares
- MACD + RSI Confluence
- StochRSI Cross
- 9/21 EMA Crossover
- The 200-day rule on SPY
- Golden Cross / Death Cross
- RSI(2) Mean Reversion
- MACD Crossover
- Bollinger Band Bounce
- Donchian / Turtle Breakout
- VWAP Bounce
- Turn-of-the-Month Effect
- Sell in May
- 12-1 Month Momentum
- Dual Momentum (GEM)
- Fear & Greed Index
- Crypto Weekend Effect
- Buy the Dip
- The January Effect
- Low-Beta Crypto
- Crypto Trend Following
- Fear & Greed Timing
- VIX Term Structure Timing
- RSI Trading Strategy
- Moving Average Crossover
- Ichimoku Cloud
- Fibonacci Retracement
- Candlestick Patterns
- Support and Resistance
- Stochastic, CCI and Williams %R
- ADX and Parabolic SAR
- Funding Rate and Open Interest
- Bollinger Band Squeeze
- Pairs Trading
- 52-Week High
- Santa Claus Rally
- ICT Liquidity Sweep
- Order Blocks
- Break of Structure
- Fair Value Gap
- ICT and Smart Money Concepts
- Supertrend
- Connors Double 7
- Bull Market Support Band
- Mayer Multiple
- Bitcoin Halving Cycle
- Awesome Oscillator
- Bollinger Band Breakout
- Turnaround Tuesday
- Gold/Silver Ratio
- Squeeze Momentum
- Larry Williams Volatility Breakout
- 20 EMA Pullback
- Guppy GMMA
- Cup and Handle
- Head and Shoulders
- Heikin-Ashi
- RSI Divergence
- Keltner Channel Breakout
- Pivot Point R1 Breakout
- Trendline Breakout
- Overnight Gap Fade
- IBS Mean Reversion
- Tickfloor vs TradingView
- Tickfloor vs Finviz
- Tickfloor vs Simply Wall St
- Tickfloor vs Stock Rover
- Tickfloor vs Koyfin
- Tickfloor vs TipRanks
- Tickfloor vs Seeking Alpha
- Tickfloor vs TrendSpider
- Tickfloor vs Tradervue
- Tickfloor vs the TradingView strategy tester
- Tickfloor vs backtesting tools (AlgoTest, Backtrex, QuantConnect)
Related tests
- ICT liquidity sweep
- ICT Asia session liquidity sweep, hourly crypto version
- The concept page: Stop loss
- The concept page: Slippage
Terms explained
About Tickfloor
What is Tickfloor?
Tickfloor (also written Tick Floor) is a stock and crypto indicator. It scores any stock or coin out of 10 from ten common chart checks and publishes every backtest, failures included. So far 1,346 strategies tested, 0 passed the luck check.
Is Tickfloor free?
Yes, to start. 1 free score, no account needed. A free account gets 3 free scores a day. No card. The example, evidence and results pages, glossary and first two lessons need no account. Paid passes unlock the rest.
How is Tickfloor different from other indicator sites?
Tickfloor publishes its test record, failures included: 1,346 strategies in 77 families against a benchmark that pays no costs. 266 finished ahead on raw results, but 0 of 1,778 tests were left once luck was allowed for. The score is not a prediction.
Can I backtest my own strategy on Tickfloor?
Yes, with a pass. The Backtest Lab runs your own daily rule on past data and shows every trade after costs. Results are exploration, not a forecast.
New to trading? Read how to start trading, or see our latest research in Tickfloor News.