Dual Momentum (GEM), QQQ/DIA/AGG proxy: does it work?
Last updated
In-sample, not a promise. Every figure we measured here comes from a backtest on past data.
Did Dual Momentum (GEM) beat the benchmark in Tickfloor's test?
No. We tested Dual Momentum (GEM) on 25 ETFs, 2005 to 2025. After costs, it returned 2.7 percentage points a year less than the benchmark. None held up once we allowed for the many other rules we tested. This is a historical test of the rule as described, not a prediction or advice.
Antonacci's Global Equities Momentum (GEM) rotation, switch between US and international stocks or bonds based on relative and absolute momentum, is one of the most repeated "set and forget" systems taught online. This page tests a proxy of it, not the published rule.
The rule we tested. Each month, using trailing 12‑month returns: if QQQ is up over the last 12 months, hold whichever of QQQ or DIA did better, otherwise hold AGG, a US bond ETF. QQQ stands in for SPY and DIA, a US large-cap index ETF, for EFA, the international developed-markets fund in the published rule. The absolute-momentum test is "QQQ's 12‑month return is above zero", because no Treasury-bill series was available, so it is not the published T-bill comparison.
- GEM dual momentum, QQQ/DIA/AGG proxy for SPY/EFA/AGG −2.7 pts/yr vs the benchmark, 11 holdings changes, p=1.000, corrected q=1.000
Receipt: parameters, data, window and result file
- Run id
- equity-factors-dual-momentum-gem, run 16 September 2026
- Frozen parameters
- universe ETFS_DAILY; rebalance monthly; timeframe 1d; lookbackMonths=12
- Data source
- vendor not recorded in the result file; data fingerprint sha256 9886d2144084c5d5...
- Instruments and coverage
- 25 assets: QQQ, DIA, XLK, XLF, XLE, XLV, XLI, XLP, XLY, XLU, XLB, XLC and 13 more (full list in the result file); QQQ stands in for SPY; DIA stands in for EFA
- Date window
- 4 January 2005 to 14 March 2025 (discovery cutoff 15 March 2025)
- Sample
- 11 holdings changes across 91 rebalances (a holdings change is a rebalance that altered what the portfolio held, not a completed trade) over 4 January 2005 to 14 March 2025 (20.2 years)
- Cost rule
- 0.05% per side; charged on every change in position/weight; benchmark pays none; no funding/borrow on shorts
- Fill rule
- not recorded
- Benchmark
- equal-weight long of the same assets, rebalanced daily across assets trading that day (no costs)
- Rule source (public)
- research/hunt2/strategies/equity-factors-dual-momentum-gem.mjs
- Run record (public)
- research/hunt2/ledger.jsonl, line with id equity-factors-dual-momentum-gem
- Full result file
- not published yet
No. None of the versions we tested passed. None held up once we allowed for how many other rules we tested. That covers the versions, costs and benchmark described here, not every version of the rule.
Tested a rule of your own? Check whether your backtest is just luck. It is free and needs no account.
Failed: only the tested version above. Not tested: The published GEM on SPY, EFA and AGG with a T-bill test; any international equity fund; other lookbacks. A result for the tested version says nothing about these.
In the stored result for GEM dual momentum, QQQ/DIA/AGG proxy for SPY/EFA/AGG, the rule's return is exactly 0.0% from 4 January 2005 to 5 February 2015, the first half of the window. Tickfloor has not established why, so read the full-period figure as a weaker test than its length suggests.
Different rules, tested separately
These are different rules, so they do not change the verdict above. They sit here so a failed proxy does not read as a failed idea.
- Dual momentum QQQ/AGG, bond instead of cash (2005+) (2 ETFs: QQQ, AGG), 4 January 2005 to 14 March 2025, costs 0.05% per side: +3.8 pts/yr vs the benchmark across 22 holdings changes across 242 rebalances (a holdings change is a rebalance that altered what the portfolio held, not a completed trade), unadjusted p=0.044, BH-adjusted q=0.869: beat the benchmark and had an unadjusted p-value under 0.05.
- Dual momentum QQQ or GLD, AGG as the safe asset (3 ETFs: QQQ, GLD, AGG), 4 January 2005 to 14 March 2025, costs 0.05% per side: +4.7 pts/yr vs the benchmark across 37 holdings changes across 242 rebalances (a holdings change is a rebalance that altered what the portfolio held, not a completed trade), unadjusted p=0.071, BH-adjusted q=0.978: beat the benchmark on the raw number, but not significantly.
This is one line in a bigger check. The research desk has run 1,346 strategies, most against an equal-weight benchmark of the same assets rebalanced daily that pays no costs (the strategies pay theirs). After correcting for how many we tried (the luck check, Benjamini‑Hochberg, 1,778 tests), 0 passed. That does not prove no strategy works, and it says nothing about versions we did not test.
Short answers: the verdict and the rule, as questions
Does Gary Antonacci's dual momentum (GEM) strategy work?
No. None of the versions we tested passed. After costs: GEM dual momentum, QQQ/DIA/AGG proxy for SPY/EFA/AGG: −2.7 pts/yr vs the benchmark. None held up once we allowed for how many other rules we tested. That covers the versions, costs and benchmark described here, not every version of the rule.
What exact rule did Tickfloor test?
Each month, using trailing 12-month returns: if QQQ is up over the last 12 months, hold whichever of QQQ or DIA did better, otherwise hold AGG, a US bond ETF. QQQ stands in for SPY and DIA, a US large-cap index ETF, for EFA, the international developed-markets fund in the published rule. The absolute-momentum test is "QQQ's 12-month return is above zero", because no Treasury-bill series was available, so it is not the published T-bill comparison.
Is this financial advice?
No. This measures a publicly claimed strategy rule, not a recommendation. General information only, not personal advice.
See the full numbers on the Equity factors family page, or the full method and every result.
Other rules we've tested
Terms explained
Next steps
- See a full worked example (free, no account)
- Start lesson 1 of the course (free)
- Run your own version of this rule in the Backtest Lab (needs a pass)
General information only. It doesn't consider your objectives, finances or needs. Tickfloor holds no financial services licence and never places trades.