Every strategy family we tested
1,346 strategies, 1,778 tests corrected together for multiple testing. 0 passed.
Every test we have published, newest first: the rule after costs, and against random-entry copies of itself.
In-sample, not a promise. Every figure here comes from a backtest on past data.
1,346 strategies, 1,778 tests corrected together for multiple testing. 0 passed.
Once we allow for luck, our best result mostly disappears, and no strategy passed the luck check. We ran 1,778 tests across 1,346 strategies. The best shows an information ratio of 0.6657 before correction and 0.1887 after correcting for the number of tests. A historical test, not advice.
Edge excluded. A composite 1, 3 and 12-month trend rule, sized by volatility, long only: −4.3 points a year against an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily across 25 ETFs, and behind both a volatility-only twin (−3.8 points) and a 200-day gate (−2.4 points). Its worst fall was 15.0% against 25.8%. 1 of 1,778 tests.
Not confirmed. The same 1, 3 and 12-month trend rule on 18 crypto pairs: −47.0 points a year against an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily. Its worst fall was 18.2% against 85.9%, but the registered sizing left it in cash most days (invested 12.5% of the time). It cut the drawdown but shows no edge. 1 of 1,778 tests.
Not confirmed. Dropping the top third of stocks by idiosyncratic risk from 12-1 momentum: −4.7 points a year against an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily, below plain 12-1 momentum (+18.9 points) and below the same filter on total volatility (−2.1 points). 1 of 1,778 tests.
Not confirmed. Half-Kelly sizing on QQQ with AGG: +4.5 points a year against an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 0.69), with a Sharpe of 0.68 against 0.82 for the volatility-targeted row it replaces. With a bond sleeve the Sharpe is 0.62 against 0.63 for a 60/40 row. 2 of 1,778 tests.
Insufficient. 13 conditioned events in 7.6 years, too few to support a claim. The plain buy-after-drop rule had 253 events and a similar mean per event (4.8% against 4.7%). Descriptive only. 1 of 1,778 tests.
Not confirmed. We re-ran the 8 best-looking stock momentum rows with costs that rise for less liquid names. 8 of 8 keep a positive point estimate over the equal-weight benchmark at those tiered costs, and 6 of 8 at double them. 0 of 8 cleared the corrected gate at flat cost (8 of 1,778 tests). The benchmark pays no costs, and the cost tiers are our assumption.
We tested five techniques that came up often on Reddit and YouTube in September and early October 2026, 16 versions in all, after costs, with the rules written down before running. None passed our pre-set test. The intraday ones are hourly crypto versions, not the 1 to 15 minute futures and stock setups people post.
Did not pass (hourly crypto analogue). Lost money before costs; 0 of 52 earlier multi-market versions passed.
Did not pass (hourly crypto, no structure confirmation). Beat 0 of 200 random copies; 0 of 1,057 sweep rules passed in the earlier study.
Did not pass (hourly crypto). Trading costs on thousands of trades swamped both versions.
Did not pass. Costs ate the plain cross; the filtered version beat random copies but trailed the basket.
Did not pass (18-coin basket). Smaller drops, smaller returns, also on the matched window; Uptober beat most random copies but not enough.
A viral clip says 81% wins. On NQ it won 90.4% of 1,641 trades and still lost 0.84 points a trade over all of them, 1.15 on the later test split, net of costs.
8 configurations on 8 Binance USD-M perpetuals. 0 of 8 passed. The best lost 0.087R a trade on the test split, net of costs.
Did not pass. Crypto rule: −3.8% a year after costs, against 62.8% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. US stocks rule: −0.3% a year after costs, against 14.2% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: −0.6% a year after costs, against 62.8% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. US stocks rule: 3.6% a year after costs, against 18.0% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 11.2% a year after costs, against 62.8% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 6.4% a year after costs, against 62.8% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 0.0% a year after costs, against 62.8% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. US stocks rule: 12.0% a year after costs, against 14.2% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. ETFs rule: 10.0% a year after costs, against 9.4% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. ETFs rule: −0.1% a year after costs, against 13.2% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Claimed 73 to 90% wins. We measured 30.6% over 252 trades, net of costs.
Claimed 75% wins. We measured 54.9% over 4,763 trades, net of costs.
Claimed 67.2% wins. Not tested alone: in a 6,428-cell indicator sweep, 0 passed the full gate.
Over 19 October 2010 to 11 September 2026 the rule returned 7.2% a year after 10bps/side per switch; SPY itself rose 12.5% a year over that window.
Did not pass. ETFs rule: 11.8% a year after costs, against 13.2% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. US stocks rule: 1.8% a year after costs, against 16.6% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 80.5% a year after costs, against 62.8% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. ETFs rule: 1.4% a year after costs, against 7.0% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 65.1% a year after costs, against 62.8% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: −49.8% a year after costs, against 84.7% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. ETFs rule: 2.8% a year after costs, against 13.2% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. ETFs rule: 6.6% a year after costs, against 13.2% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. US stocks rule: 26.8% a year after costs, against 18.0% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. ETFs rule: 4.2% a year after costs, against 7.0% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 8.3% a year after costs, against 48.1% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 5.9% a year after costs, against 62.8% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. US stocks rule: 13.1% a year after costs, against 14.2% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. US stocks rule: 1.1% a year after costs, against 14.2% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Ahead of the benchmark before correction, not after. Crypto rule: 101.7% a year after costs, against 62.8% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 0.62).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 88.8% a year after costs, against 62.8% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Ahead of the benchmark before correction, not after. Crypto rule: 103.3% a year after costs, against 62.8% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 0.96).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 83.0% a year after costs, against 62.8% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 55.5% a year after costs, against 62.8% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 86.0% a year after costs, against 62.8% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 20.9% a year after costs, against 62.8% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: −49.6% a year after costs, against 84.7% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: −15.2% a year after costs, against 84.7% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: −78.3% a year after costs, against 84.7% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: −20.6% a year after costs, against 84.7% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: −15.2% a year after costs, against 84.7% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 68.8% a year after costs, against 62.8% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. US stocks rule: 3.2% a year after costs, against 16.6% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 32.0% a year after costs, against 29.6% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 9.8% a year after costs, against 32.3% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 98.7% a year after costs, against 62.8% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 89.0% a year after costs, against 62.8% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 72.1% a year after costs, against 62.8% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. ETFs rule: 2.2% a year after costs, against 11.6% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. ETFs rule: −1.7% a year after costs, against 9.2% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. US stocks rule: 2.9% a year after costs, against 18.0% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. US stocks rule: −0.9% a year after costs, against 14.2% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. US stocks rule: 4.8% a year after costs, against 17.6% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 59.8% a year after costs, against 51.9% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. US stocks rule: 0.3% a year after costs, against 16.9% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. US stocks rule: 0.0% a year after costs, against 18.0% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. US stocks rule: −0.1% a year after costs, against 18.0% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. US stocks rule: 1.3% a year after costs, against 18.0% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. US stocks rule: 5.2% a year after costs, against 18.0% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 45.9% a year after costs, against 84.7% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. Crypto rule: 35.6% a year after costs, against 84.7% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. ETFs rule: 1.8% a year after costs, against 11.6% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Did not pass. ETFs rule: 8.5% a year after costs, against 13.2% for an equal-weight basket of the same assets, rebalanced daily (corrected q 1.00).
Each family's size shows how many strategies we tested, and its colours show how each one did. Pick a family to open its page.
Families by number of strategies; bar colours are the outcomes above.
Historical backtests net of modelled costs, not a recommendation. A colour describes one strategy's result over its test window and says nothing about future returns.
Historical backtests, not live trading, and none is a recommendation. See the testing standard and the evidence page.
General information only. It doesn't consider your objectives, finances or needs. Tickfloor holds no financial services licence and never places trades.