Does the VWAP and 9 EMA strategy work? An hourly crypto version, backtested
Last updated
In-sample, not a promise. Every figure we measured here comes from a backtest on past data.
Does trading VWAP work?
The hourly crypto VWAP rules we tested did not pass after costs. One made money before costs and lost it to trading costs. We did not test 1 to 5 minute stock charts.
Neither hourly crypto version passed our pre-set test. The trend version made -48.6% a year before costs and -99.1% after, and beat 2 of 200 random copies. The reclaim version made money before costs (32.3% a year) and lost it to costs (-73.5%).
Hypothetical historical backtest on cached data to March 2025, not live results and not indicative of future performance. General information only. It doesn't consider your objectives, finances or needs. Tickfloor holds no financial services licence and never places trades.
Correction, 6 October 2026: what we fixed after review
What people say
VWAP, the volume-weighted average price of the day, is pitched as the line institutions trade around. The popular setups pair it with a fast 9-period EMA: be long when price is above both, short when below both, or buy the moment price reclaims VWAP and ride it until it loses the 9 EMA.
- "I don't use a ton of indicators, mainly VWAP and 9 EMA" (r/options post, 24 Sep 2026)
- "A VWAP reclaim would look clean on the chart" (r/Daytrading post, 16 Sep 2026)
In our archive sample of five trading subreddits (1 September to 5 October 2026), 110 posts mentioned VWAP. On YouTube on 5 October, Mind Math Money's "Stop Guessing Entries. Use This VWAP Trading Strategy Instead." had 82,770 views and BrandonTrades' "Ultimate VWAP Strategy for Day Trading" had 17,248.
What we tested
This is a proxy. Day traders run these setups on 1 to 5 minute stock and futures charts. Our harness has hourly crypto with exchange volume, so VWAP here is an hourly estimate (typical price times volume, restarting each UTC day), not the exact traded-price VWAP a chart platform shows. We wrote down two versions and the pass bar before running, and add one VWAP rule from an earlier batch.
- Long above the session VWAP (hourly OHLCV estimate) and the 9 EMA, short below both. VWAP restarts at 00:00 UTC each day and is estimated from hourly bars (typical price times volume). At each hourly close, hold a long while the close is above both VWAP and the 9-hour EMA, a short while it is below both, and nothing when they disagree or on the first bar of the day.
- VWAP reclaim (hourly OHLCV estimate), long only, exit on a close below the 9 EMA, out by the 00:00 UTC close. Long only. Buy when the hourly close moves from below VWAP to above it (the reclaim). Sell on a close below the 9 EMA, and by the 00:00 UTC close at the latest.
- Bounce off a rolling 20-hour VWAP (earlier run). Buy a dip below a rolling 20-hour VWAP and hold for the bounce. Reused from an earlier batch.
Results
| Version | Market (assets) | Trades | Rule, a year (after costs) | Benchmark, a year | Ahead or behind, a year | Same, before costs | Random copies beaten (share of 200) | p | q (all tests) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Long above the session VWAP (hourly OHLCV estimate) and the 9 EMA, short below both | crypto (8) | 100,047 | -99.1% | 84.7% | -183.8 pts | -133.3 pts | 1.0% | 1.00 | 1.00 |
| VWAP reclaim (hourly OHLCV estimate), long only, exit on a close below the 9 EMA, out by the 00:00 UTC close | crypto (8) | 39,677 | -73.5% | 84.7% | -158.2 pts | -52.4 pts | 68.0% | 1.00 | 1.00 |
| Bounce off a rolling 20-hour VWAP (earlier run) | crypto (8) | 16,833 | -49.8% | 84.7% | -134.5 pts | -85.8 pts | 3.5% | 1.00 | 1.00 |
- Long above the session VWAP (hourly OHLCV estimate) and the 9 EMA, short below both
- Market (assets)
- crypto (8)
- Trades
- 100,047
- Rule, a year (after costs)
- -99.1%
- Benchmark, a year
- 84.7%
- Ahead or behind, a year
- -183.8 pts
- Same, before costs
- -133.3 pts
- Random copies beaten (share of 200)
- 1.0%
- p
- 1.00
- q (all tests)
- 1.00
- VWAP reclaim (hourly OHLCV estimate), long only, exit on a close below the 9 EMA, out by the 00:00 UTC close
- Market (assets)
- crypto (8)
- Trades
- 39,677
- Rule, a year (after costs)
- -73.5%
- Benchmark, a year
- 84.7%
- Ahead or behind, a year
- -158.2 pts
- Same, before costs
- -52.4 pts
- Random copies beaten (share of 200)
- 68.0%
- p
- 1.00
- q (all tests)
- 1.00
- Bounce off a rolling 20-hour VWAP (earlier run)
- Market (assets)
- crypto (8)
- Trades
- 16,833
- Rule, a year (after costs)
- -49.8%
- Benchmark, a year
- 84.7%
- Ahead or behind, a year
- -134.5 pts
- Same, before costs
- -85.8 pts
- Random copies beaten (share of 200)
- 3.5%
- p
- 1.00
- q (all tests)
- 1.00
Read the numbers with this in mind. The benchmark is always fully invested and pays no costs, and from 2017 to early 2025 crypto rose a lot, so any rule that spends much of its time in cash trails it by a wide margin almost automatically. That gap answers a narrow question, not whether the rule is useful. So we also compare each rule with 200 copies of itself: its own trades, with the same holding times, the same long and short sides and the same costs, shifted together to a random point in time, the same shift for every market it trades. Those copies are in the market exactly as much as the rule is, so they ask a different question: did the rule pick better moments than chance? The copies are not held to the same hours of the day. The trend version is in the market most of the time, long or short, so its gap to the benchmark is mostly about trading, not about sitting out.
The trend version beat 2 of 200 random copies: copies with the same trades at random times did better.
What costs do to it
Crypto pays 0.10% a side plus a per-coin slippage measured from the Binance order book on 8 September 2026 for a $1,000 order, applied to the whole 2017 to 2025 window (a present-day snapshot, not historical spreads). US stocks and ETFs pay 0.05% a side. The cost is charged every time the position changes, including a flip from long to short. Shorts pay no borrow or funding; their net effect is not measured here. This is where these VWAP rules fell over. The trend version made 100,047 trades in about seven and a half years across 8 coins, roughly one every few hours per coin. The reclaim version, which only buys, was positive before costs at 32.3% a year (the basket made 84.7%), and 39,677 trades of fees and slippage took it to -73.5%.
What the result does and does not show
VWAP is a useful reference for judging your own fills, which is what large traders use it for. As an hourly signal, crossing it is common: price goes back and forth across a slow-moving average many times a day.
Adding the 9 EMA filters some of those crossings, but in this test not enough to pay for the trading. Every trade pays the spread and the fee, and the trend version trades a lot.
The reclaim version looked better before costs, but it still trailed the basket it was trading, and by more after costs. At these costs it did not hold up; with cheaper execution the answer could differ, and we did not test a cost range here.
What a beginner should take away
- VWAP tells you the average price paid today. On its own it does not tell you what happens next.
- Before trusting any intraday rule, count how often it trades and multiply by your real cost per trade.
- If a rule only looks good on a chart you marked up afterwards, test it on data you had not seen. The r/Daytrading post above is a good example of someone finding that out.
Try it yourself
The Lab has no VWAP and cannot reproduce the basket test above. A related daily exercise with the 9 EMA, not this rule: on QQQ, set the entry to price crosses above ema(9) and the exit to price crosses below ema(9). Watch how many trades it makes and what the costs do.
The Lab tests one rule on one stock, fills at the next open and shows win rate, average trade and worst drop after costs, so its figures will not match the basket results above.
A pass opens every course lesson, the full research tabs and more Lab runs on all 50 Lab stocks. It does not include trade signals or a system that wins.
Receipt: data, costs, files
- Engine
- Tickfloor research harness (research/hunt2), the one behind the published strategy registry
- Pre-registration
- prereg.md, committed before any run; prereg-amendment-2026-10-06.md and prereg-amendment-2026-10-06b.md, each committed before its corrected runs
- Random control
- Version 3 (6 October 2026): every copy is the rule's own trades shifted to a random point in time, the same shift for every market it trades
- Window
- 17 August 2017 to 14 March 2025 for the best-faith version; data stops before 15 March 2025 (later data is held back)
- Cells
- tr5-vwap-ema9-trend, tr5-vwap-reclaim-ema9-exit, social-ta-vwap-bounce (earlier run, reused)
- Multiple testing
- q is Benjamini-Hochberg over all 722 tests in the published family, these included
- Result files
- results-amended-2026-10-06b.json (current), results-amended-2026-10-06.json (control v2, superseded) and results.json (archived, as first published), with every rule's code and sha256 hashes
Limits and caveats
Limits
The setups are usually traded on 1 to 5 minute stock charts. We tested hourly crypto, which trades 24 hours, so VWAP restarts at midnight UTC rather than at the 9:30 open, and it is an hourly estimate.
Exits are on hourly closes.
The random copies are not held to the same hours of the day.
Shorts pay no borrow or funding cost here; the net effect is not measured.
Correction, 6 October 2026
- Our random-date copies had a bug. When two copies of trades in the same direction landed next to each other, they merged into one trade, and the exit and re-entry costs between them were never charged. So the copies traded less and paid less than the rule they were copying, which made the rule look worse against them. We fixed the code so every copy keeps the rule's trade count and costs, wrote the fix down in a dated amendment before re-running, and re-ran every copy. A second check the same day found a deeper problem. The fixed copies still moved each market's trades on their own, so a rule that is in many related markets at the same moments (a moving-average rule on 8 crypto pairs, say) was compared with copies that spread those bets out. Spread-out bets bunch more tightly, so the rule landed far above or far below its copies too often: coin-flip rules beat 95% of their copies about three times as often as chance allows, mostly on US stocks. We changed the copies again, wrote that down in a second dated amendment before re-running, and re-ran every copy. Each copy now shifts the rule's own trades to a random point in time, the same shift for every market. On 600 coin-flip rules, 7.0% (same timing in every market) and 5.3% (own timing per market) now beat 95% of their copies, close to the 5% chance allows. On this page: copies beaten out of 200, as first published, after the first fix and now: trend version: 0 -> 0 -> 2; reclaim version: 40 -> 124 -> 136; VWAP bounce: 3 -> 12 -> 7.
- The growth-of-$1 chart said the trend version ended at $0. That was rounding: it ended far below a hundredth of a cent, but not at zero. The chart now keeps full precision.
- We said VWAP was computed "the proper way". It is an hourly estimate from typical price and volume, not exact traded-price VWAP. We called the trade count "position changes"; it counts trades. The reclaim exit happens at the 00:00 UTC close, not 23:00.
The original pre-registration, results and test ledger are unchanged; these corrections are new, dated files. Evidence files
Short answers (FAQ)
Why use crypto to test a stock strategy?
It is the intraday data our research harness has, and it has exchange volume to estimate VWAP from. Stock and futures results could differ.
Is this advice?
No. It reports what happened to a set of rules in a historical backtest. General information only.
More trending techniques we tested
- Does the opening range breakout work? An hourly crypto version, backtested
- Does the ICT Asia session liquidity sweep work? An hourly crypto version, backtested
- Does the 9/21 EMA crossover work? We tested it on thousands of trades
- The 200-day line, the golden cross and Uptober: tested on 18 coins including Bitcoin
- Five widely discussed trading techniques of autumn 2026, tested
- Every popular rule we tested
How we set the rules, costs and pass bar before running anything: the Tickfloor testing standard. The wider record is on the evidence page.