Five widely discussed trading techniques of autumn 2026, tested
We tested five techniques that came up often on Reddit and YouTube in September and early October 2026, 19 versions in all, after costs, with the rules written down before running. None passed our pre-set test. The intraday ones are hourly crypto versions, not the 1 to 15 minute futures and stock setups people post.
Hypothetical historical backtest on cached data to March 2025, not live results and not indicative of future performance. General information only. It doesn't consider your objectives, finances or needs. Tickfloor holds no financial services licence and never places trades.
Correction, 6 October 2026: what we fixed after review
How we picked them: keyword counts in an archive of posts from r/Daytrading, r/Trading, r/algotrading, r/Forex and r/options, 1 September to 5 October 2026 (not cleaned of noise, and coverage differs by subreddit), plus YouTube views on recent videos, then keeping what our harness could test. ICT and smart money terms led with 240 posts, then breakouts, VWAP and moving averages; ORB had 80. AI trading bots (204) were left out because they are a way of building rules, not a rule. On crypto, the 200-day line, the golden cross and Uptober came round again. This is a sample, not a ranking of the whole year.
Each technique got a best-faith version and two or three common variants. They ran on Tickfloor's research harness, and every run joined the same correction for multiple tests: 722 tests in that family, 0 passed. That family covers the harness's strategy hunt; separate studies (such as our opening-range index study) have their own corrections.
The five, at a glance
| Technique | Verdict | Best-faith rule a year vs basket, after costs | Random copies beaten |
|---|---|---|---|
| Opening range breakout (ORB), hourly crypto version | Did not pass (hourly crypto analogue). Lost money before costs; 0 of 52 earlier multi-market versions passed. | -58.3% vs 84.7% | 0 of 200 |
| ICT Asia session liquidity sweep, hourly crypto version | Did not pass (hourly crypto, no structure confirmation). Beat 0 of 200 random copies; 0 of 1,057 sweep rules passed in the earlier study. | -48.1% vs 84.7% | 0 of 200 |
| VWAP plus 9 EMA, hourly crypto version | Did not pass (hourly crypto). Trading costs on thousands of trades swamped both versions. | -99.1% vs 84.7% | 2 of 200 |
| 9/21 EMA crossover | Did not pass. Costs ate the plain cross (it beat its random copies but lost money); the filtered version beat random copies but trailed the basket. | -51.3% vs 84.7% | 191 of 200 |
| Crypto 200-day line, golden cross and Uptober | Did not pass (18-coin basket). Smaller drops, smaller returns, also on the matched window; Uptober beat most random copies but not enough. | 14.2% vs 62.8% | 108 of 200 |
- Opening range breakout (ORB), hourly crypto version
- Verdict
- Did not pass (hourly crypto analogue). Lost money before costs; 0 of 52 earlier multi-market versions passed.
- Best-faith rule a year vs basket, after costs
- -58.3% vs 84.7%
- Random copies beaten
- 0 of 200
- ICT Asia session liquidity sweep, hourly crypto version
- Verdict
- Did not pass (hourly crypto, no structure confirmation). Beat 0 of 200 random copies; 0 of 1,057 sweep rules passed in the earlier study.
- Best-faith rule a year vs basket, after costs
- -48.1% vs 84.7%
- Random copies beaten
- 0 of 200
- VWAP plus 9 EMA, hourly crypto version
- Verdict
- Did not pass (hourly crypto). Trading costs on thousands of trades swamped both versions.
- Best-faith rule a year vs basket, after costs
- -99.1% vs 84.7%
- Random copies beaten
- 2 of 200
- 9/21 EMA crossover
- Verdict
- Did not pass. Costs ate the plain cross (it beat its random copies but lost money); the filtered version beat random copies but trailed the basket.
- Best-faith rule a year vs basket, after costs
- -51.3% vs 84.7%
- Random copies beaten
- 191 of 200
- Crypto 200-day line, golden cross and Uptober
- Verdict
- Did not pass (18-coin basket). Smaller drops, smaller returns, also on the matched window; Uptober beat most random copies but not enough.
- Best-faith rule a year vs basket, after costs
- 14.2% vs 62.8%
- Random copies beaten
- 108 of 200
How we tested
The pass bar is the one every strategy in the harness faces. After correcting for every test in its 722-test family, the rule must beat an equal-weight basket of the same assets that pays no costs. It must also beat at least 95% of 200 copies of itself with its trades shifted to a random point in time, make money after costs, and do it in both halves of the window, with at least 30 trades. Failing that bar means a rule did not show an advantage on these data and costs; it does not prove the idea can never work.
The intraday techniques (ORB, ICT sweeps, VWAP, the 9/21 cross) ran on hourly crypto, the only intraday data in the harness. They are proxies for setups usually traded on 1 to 15 minute futures and stock charts. For ORB and the ICT sweep we also report our earlier index CFD and stock studies, with their own scope. Each article says exactly what was tested and where it differs from the version people post.
What the five have in common
The intraday rules lost money or trailed badly once costs were in, and most were losing before costs too. The slower crypto rules cut the worst drops and gave up more return, also when scored from the day their averages exist. The closest calls on timing were the 9/21 cross, which beat 191 of 200 random copies while it still lost money after costs, and Uptober, which beat 140 of 200 on eight Octobers. Neither cleared every gate.
None of this means no one can make money with these ideas. It means these mechanical versions did not meet our pre-set criteria in years of data, and the short winning streaks posted online are not evidence that they do.
Read each test
- Does the opening range breakout work? An hourly crypto version, backtested
- Does the ICT Asia session liquidity sweep work? An hourly crypto version, backtested
- Does the VWAP and 9 EMA strategy work? An hourly crypto version, backtested
- Does the 9/21 EMA crossover work? We tested it on thousands of trades
- The 200-day line, the golden cross and Uptober: tested on 18 coins including Bitcoin
- See a full worked example (free, no account)
- Start lesson 1 of the course (free)
- Every popular rule we tested
Correction, 6 October 2026
- Our random-date copies had a bug. When two copies of trades in the same direction landed next to each other, they merged into one trade, and the exit and re-entry costs between them were never charged. So the copies traded less and paid less than the rule they were copying, which made the rule look worse against them. We fixed the code so every copy keeps the rule's trade count and costs, wrote the fix down in a dated amendment before re-running, and re-ran every copy. A second check the same day found a deeper problem. The fixed copies still moved each market's trades on their own, so a rule that is in many related markets at the same moments (a moving-average rule on 8 crypto pairs, say) was compared with copies that spread those bets out. Spread-out bets bunch more tightly, so the rule landed far above or far below its copies too often: coin-flip rules beat 95% of their copies about three times as often as chance allows, mostly on US stocks. We changed the copies again, wrote that down in a second dated amendment before re-running, and re-ran every copy. Each copy now shifts the rule's own trades to a random point in time, the same shift for every market. On 600 coin-flip rules, 7.0% (same timing in every market) and 5.3% (own timing per market) now beat 95% of their copies, close to the 5% chance allows. 12 of the 16 original versions' random-copy numbers changed; no pass or fail verdict changed. Each article lists its own changes.
- Our review also found descriptions that did not match the code (an ORB target, an ICT "no stop" version that kept its stop, execution times), a scoring unfairness for the slow 200-day rules, and headlines that overstated what was tested. The intraday tests are hourly crypto proxies, and the articles now say so first. We registered two new runs (a true no-stop ICT version and matched-window 200-day scores) before running them.
- We called these "the five most-talked-about" techniques. Our sample supports "widely discussed", not a ranking. And the "every test we have ever run" count is the harness's family only.
The original pre-registration, results and test ledger are unchanged; these corrections are new, dated files. Evidence files
Short answers (FAQ)
Which trading strategy works best in 2026?
None of the five techniques we tested passed our test. Across the 722 tests in the harness's family, 0 have passed.
How did you pick the five?
From keyword counts in an archive of five trading subreddits from 1 September to 5 October 2026 and YouTube views on recent videos, then keeping the ones our harness could test. It is a sample, not a ranking.
Can I test these myself?
The Backtest Lab offers related daily-bar exercises with a free account; it cannot reproduce these basket tests. The rule code, pre-registration and results are in the evidence files.
Is this advice?
No. It reports what happened to a set of rules in a historical backtest. General information only.