Do trading strategies work on ETFs?
None of the technical indicators and other rules passed the corrected test in these backtests. Of 366 strategies tested on ETFs, 70 finished ahead of the equal-weight benchmark on the point estimate, 18 of those with an unadjusted p-value under 0.05, and none met the corrected Benjamini-Hochberg bar (q below 0.10). The median strategy returned −3.8 pts/yr against the benchmark. These are results from our older test setup, which was built before our current testing rules. They have not been redone under those rules.
The universe is ETFs only, with data up to 15 March 2025. Technical analysis here means rules built from price and volume, such as moving averages, RSI and MACD; the technical indicators were tested alongside other rules, such as seasonality. Most strategies are published or popular rules coded from a source description (a few are Tickfloor research-desk hypotheses), charged modelled trading costs and scored against an equal-weight benchmark of the same assets.
The numbers
- 366 strategies tested on ETFs.
- 70 finished ahead of the benchmark on the point estimate, 18 with an unadjusted p-value under 0.05.
- None met the corrected bar (q below 0.10).
- The median strategy returned −3.8 pts/yr against the benchmark.
Research map: ETFs
Each family's size shows how many strategies we tested, and its colours show how each one did. Pick a family to open its page.
- Edge excluded 64
- Behind, not excluded 173
- Behind, one good half 46
- Too few trades 13
- Ahead, not significant 70
Families by number of strategies; bar colours are the outcomes above.
- Trend following62
- Momentum56
- Volatility38
- Mean reversion35
- Macro34
- Day and month seasonality30
- Other tested patterns27
- Macro and intermarket12
- Popular rules, strongest version7
- Managed futures trend6
- Social media chart patterns6
- Pairs and stat arb5
All 38 families
- Rebalance control5
- Sentiment extremes5
- Calendar-event drift4
- Oil shock attribution3
- Rate decomposition3
- Capital deployment2
- Credit vol disagreement2
- Higher-timeframe cascade2
- Liquidity sweep2
- Macro disagreement2
- Popular indicator rules2
- Volatility disagreement2
- Age price barrier1
- Alternative-data sentiment1
- Breadth1
- Chart structure1
- Equity factors1
- Excursion balance1
- Funding carry1
- Index alignment1
- Judas swing1
- Order block1
- Premium discount1
- Sequential evidence1
- Tail budget1
- Wealth mixture1
Historical backtests net of modelled costs, not a recommendation. A colour describes one strategy's result over its test window and says nothing about future returns.
The closest results
These five came out furthest ahead of the benchmark. Being furthest ahead among 366 tries is what luck alone produces, which is why the corrected q matters more than the headline figure.
- 9-ETF dual momentum with the absolute-momentum hurdle set to SHY's 12-month return (textbook GEM), monthly (Trend following): +8.1 pts/yr vs the benchmark, unadjusted p=0.011, corrected q=0.693.
- Second 9-ETF dual momentum: XLK, XLV, XLE, GLD, VNQ vs AGG, IEF, TLT with the SHY hurdle, monthly (Trend following): +7.2 pts/yr vs the benchmark, unadjusted p=0.015, corrected q=0.693.
- Dual momentum across five risk ETFs (QQQ, DIA, GLD, DBC, VNQ) versus four safe ETFs (AGG, IEF, TLT, SHY), monthly (Trend following): +7.1 pts/yr vs the benchmark, unadjusted p=0.023, corrected q=0.746.
- 9-ETF dual momentum with a 20% volatility-managed overlay on the risk holding, remainder in the best safe ETF, monthly (Trend following): +6.9 pts/yr vs the benchmark, unadjusted p=0.012, corrected q=0.693.
- 9-ETF dual momentum with the SHY hurdle and the 20% volatility overlay together, remainder in the best bond, monthly (Trend following): +6.8 pts/yr vs the benchmark, unadjusted p=0.011, corrected q=0.693.
Tickfloor's research desk has backtested 1,346 strategies, most against an equal-weight benchmark of the same assets rebalanced daily that pays no costs (the strategies pay theirs). After correcting for the 1,778 tests run, 0 passed. That does not prove no strategy works. These are results from our older test setup, which was built before our current testing rules. They have not been redone under those rules.
General information only. It doesn't consider your objectives, finances or needs. Tickfloor holds no financial services licence and never places trades.
Strategy families tested on ETFs
- Trend following (62 on ETFs)
- Momentum (56 on ETFs)
- Volatility (38 on ETFs)
- Mean reversion (35 on ETFs)
- Macro (34 on ETFs)
- Day and month seasonality (30 on ETFs)
- Other tested patterns (27 on ETFs)
- Macro and intermarket (12 on ETFs)
Do trading strategies work on ETFs?
None of the technical indicators and other rules passed the corrected test in these backtests. Of 366 strategies tested on ETFs, 70 finished ahead of the equal-weight benchmark on the point estimate, 18 of those with an unadjusted p-value under 0.05, and none met the corrected Benjamini-Hochberg bar (q below 0.10). The median strategy returned −3.8 pts/yr against the benchmark. These are results from our older test setup, which was built before our current testing rules. They have not been redone under those rules.
What is the benchmark?
An equal-weight long position in the same assets, rebalanced daily, with no trading costs taken off it. The strategies pay trading costs and the benchmark does not, which makes the test harder to pass, not easier.
Why correct the p-values?
When 1,778 tests are run, some will look significant by luck. The Benjamini-Hochberg correction accounts for how many were tried before calling any result real.
Is this advice on what to trade?
No. It reports what happened to published and popular rules in the past. General information only, not personal advice.
More
- Strategies tested on crypto pairs
- Strategies tested on US stocks
- Every popular rule we tested
- Trading glossary
- The full method and every result