Tickfloor

Rebalance control backtests: 5 tested

Data last updated

Tests of when to rebalance an ETF portfolio, set against rebalancing on a plain schedule.

In-sample, not a promise. Every figure here comes from a backtest on past data.

0 of 5 strategies finished ahead of the benchmark. None passed the luck check, which allows for all 1,778 tests we ran (a corrected q under 0.10), so no result here is a proven edge. Scored 5 November 2026, using data up to 15 March 2025.

These strategies were tested on ETFs. See the full family index, the full method and every result, or download the raw registry (JSON).

How to read these results

"Vs benchmark" is the strategy's annualized return minus an equal-weight benchmark, rebalanced daily, on the same assets and days. Strategies are charged trading costs; the benchmark pays none. Ahead is not a confirmed edge: the p-value is the unadjusted chance of a gap this large by luck, and the corrected q (the luck check: passed below 0.10) allows for how many strategies were tried, because testing hundreds of ideas throws up lucky winners. Every strategy saw only data up to the same cutoff date. The receipt is the frozen result file for that rule.

"Sample" is trades for rules that enter and exit a position, and rebalances for portfolio rules. A rebalance is a scheduled date on which a portfolio rule re-ranks and held at least one position. It is the sample size for portfolio rules. A holdings change is a rebalance where what the portfolio held, or its weights, differed from the previous one. Only these cost money to trade. The two are different counts and are never swapped. Definitions.

Results

RuleMarketVs benchmarkSamplep-valueCorrected qDetails
Does market activity give a better ETF rebalance clock?
Source: retail trading content: quadratic variation business time ETF portfolio rebalance clock
ETFs−1.1 pts/yr2,009 rebalances1.0001.000On-site receipt
Does limiting an ETF rotation to one replacement work?
Source: retail trading content: turnover constrained ETF momentum portfolio one replacement per rebalance
ETFs−1.9 pts/yr417 rebalances1.0001.000On-site receipt
Does confirming the whole ETF target portfolio reduce false rotations?
Source: retail trading content: debounce whole target portfolio five day confirmation ETF rebalancing
ETFs−3.6 pts/yr2,009 rebalances1.0001.000On-site receipt
Does correcting only the largest ETF allocation gap work?
Source: retail trading content: pairwise extreme sleeve transfer rebalancing four asset portfolio
ETFs−6.3 pts/yr2,135 rebalances1.0001.000On-site receipt
Does accumulated allocation error give a better ETF reset rule?
Source: retail trading content: accumulated tracking error budget portfolio rebalancing
ETFs−6.4 pts/yr2,135 rebalances1.0001.000On-site receipt
  • Does market activity give a better ETF rebalance clock?

    Luck check: failed (q 1.000) −1.1 pts/yr ETFs 2,009 rebalances

    Source, p-value and result file
    Source
    retail trading content: quadratic variation business time ETF portfolio rebalance clock
    p-value
    1.000
    Corrected q
    1.000
  • Does limiting an ETF rotation to one replacement work?

    Luck check: failed (q 1.000) −1.9 pts/yr ETFs 417 rebalances

    Source, p-value and result file
    Source
    retail trading content: turnover constrained ETF momentum portfolio one replacement per rebalance
    p-value
    1.000
    Corrected q
    1.000
  • Does confirming the whole ETF target portfolio reduce false rotations?

    Luck check: failed (q 1.000) −3.6 pts/yr ETFs 2,009 rebalances

    Source, p-value and result file
    Source
    retail trading content: debounce whole target portfolio five day confirmation ETF rebalancing
    p-value
    1.000
    Corrected q
    1.000
  • Does correcting only the largest ETF allocation gap work?

    Luck check: failed (q 1.000) −6.3 pts/yr ETFs 2,135 rebalances

    Source, p-value and result file
    Source
    retail trading content: pairwise extreme sleeve transfer rebalancing four asset portfolio
    p-value
    1.000
    Corrected q
    1.000
  • Does accumulated allocation error give a better ETF reset rule?

    Luck check: failed (q 1.000) −6.4 pts/yr ETFs 2,135 rebalances

    Source, p-value and result file
    Source
    retail trading content: accumulated tracking error budget portfolio rebalancing
    p-value
    1.000
    Corrected q
    1.000

Other families