Profit disposition backtests: 3 tested
Data last updated
Exit rules for what to do with a winning trade, such as moving the stop to breakeven or selling half.
In-sample, not a promise. Every figure here comes from a backtest on past data.
0 of 3 strategies finished ahead of the benchmark. None passed the luck check, which allows for all 1,778 tests we ran (a corrected q under 0.10), so no result here is a proven edge. Scored 5 November 2026, using data up to 15 March 2025.
These strategies were tested on US stocks. See the full family index, the full method and every result, or download the raw registry (JSON).
How to read these results
"Vs benchmark" is the strategy's annualized return minus an equal-weight benchmark, rebalanced daily, on the same assets and days. Strategies are charged trading costs; the benchmark pays none. Ahead is not a confirmed edge: the p-value is the unadjusted chance of a gap this large by luck, and the corrected q (the luck check: passed below 0.10) allows for how many strategies were tried, because testing hundreds of ideas throws up lucky winners. Every strategy saw only data up to the same cutoff date. The receipt is the frozen result file for that rule.
"Sample" is trades for rules that enter and exit a position, and rebalances for portfolio rules. A rebalance is a scheduled date on which a portfolio rule re-ranks and held at least one position. It is the sample size for portfolio rules. A holdings change is a rebalance where what the portfolio held, or its weights, differed from the previous one. Only these cost money to trade. The two are different counts and are never swapped. Definitions.
Results
| Rule | Market | Vs benchmark | Sample | p-value | Corrected q | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Does moving a stock exit to breakeven after a gain work? Source: retail trading content: move stop to breakeven after four percent profit stock trade | US stocks | −3.8 pts/yr | 3,960 trades | 1.000 | 1.000 | On-site receipt |
| Does taking half the stock profit position early work? Source: retail trading content: sell half after five percent profit stock position harvesting | US stocks | −7.2 pts/yr | 1,975 rebalances | 1.000 | 1.000 | On-site receipt |
| Does giving back accumulated gains identify a bad stock hold? Source: retail trading content: exit trade cumulative gains losses participation giveback | US stocks | −13.2 pts/yr | 3,960 trades | 1.000 | 1.000 | On-site receipt |
- Does moving a stock exit to breakeven after a gain work?
Source, p-value and result file
- Source
- retail trading content: move stop to breakeven after four percent profit stock trade
- p-value
- 1.000
- Corrected q
- 1.000
- Receipt
- On-site receipt
- Does taking half the stock profit position early work?
Source, p-value and result file
- Source
- retail trading content: sell half after five percent profit stock position harvesting
- p-value
- 1.000
- Corrected q
- 1.000
- Receipt
- On-site receipt
- Does giving back accumulated gains identify a bad stock hold?
Source, p-value and result file
- Source
- retail trading content: exit trade cumulative gains losses participation giveback
- p-value
- 1.000
- Corrected q
- 1.000
- Receipt
- On-site receipt